A Guide to Gold Coast’s Italian Restaurant Scene
Living in Chicago with an Italian gives me an advantage: not only am I fortunate to have access some exceptional Italian dining options in Chicago’s Gold Coast neighborhood, I’ve got a built in critic. After all, no one makes Italian Sunday gravy like Mom, right?
The Gold Coast is a hub of Italian cuisine, featuring cozy trattorias and sophisticated enotecas that capture the authentic flavors of Italy when we can’t make it over to Taylor Street, Here are my top picks for experiencing la dolce vita without leaving the neighborhood.
Experience La Dolce Vita: Casual Comfort Food & Homey Classics
Eduardo’s Enoteca
Address: 1212 N Dearborn St
For a swanky yet low-key night of sampling Italian vinos and savory small plates, Eduardo’s never lets me down. In fact, they catered my husband’s 60th birthday party a few years back and he’s still talking about the Polpette alla Napoletana, meatballs and pancetta marinara on a baguette. This intimate, dimly-lit enoteca serves some of the most authentic Italian in the city alongside an exceptional, curated list of bottles. It’s my go-to for indulging in everything from crispy arancini to creamy burrata with a date or couple of friends.
Eduardo’s Enoteca offers an intimate, dimly lit setting perfect for sampling Italian wines and savory small plates. In fact, my daughter and I first discovered it as we walked home from North Avenue beach one pretty fall afternoon. Their authentic cicchetti, such as crispy arancini and creamy burrata, pair beautifully with a curated selection of wines. It’s an ideal spot for a cozy evening with friends or a romantic date.
Mario’s Table
Address: 21 W Goethe St
For a homey, no-frills Italian experience, Mario’s Table is a family-owned gem nestled among the tree-lined streets of the Gold Coast. The warm, welcoming atmosphere complements a menu of house-made pastas, rustic entrées, and wood-fired pizzas. During summer, their sidewalk seating offers a delightful way to enjoy the lively neighborhood ambiance.
Upscale Ambiance & Modern Takes: Refined Italian Cuisine with a Twist
La Storia
Address: 1154 N Dearborn St
La Storia elevates simple, seasonal Italian fare without sacrificing warmth and comfort. Their house-made pastas and fresh crudo are highlights, and the lush sidewalk patio evokes the essence of a Tuscan escape.
Adalina
Address: 912 N State St
Adalina offers modern, refined Italian cuisine with an inventive twist. Their menu features bright crudo plates, flavorful handmade pastas, and wood-fired entrées. The thoughtful wine program enhances the dining experience, making it a must-visit for those seeking contemporary Italian dishes.
Savor the Spirit of Italy: Family-Style Feasts & Hearty Portions
The Rosebud on Rush
Address: 720 N Rush St
A Chicago institution for over 20 years, The Rosebud on Rush serves generous portions of classic Italian-American comfort food. Family-style platters of chicken parmesan, meatballs, and fettuccine Alfredo are accompanied by crusty bread. Be sure to capture a photo with their iconic sign out front.
Carmine’s Chicago: My Go-To Spot for Classic Italian Feasts
Address: 1043 N Rush St, Chicago, IL 60611
If there’s one place I find myself returning to again and again for Italian comfort food in the Gold Coast, it’s Carmine’s. This iconic Rush Street spot has everything I love about classic Italian dining—hearty portions, a lively atmosphere, and that perfect mix of old-school charm and big-city energy.
Whether I’m in the mood for a towering plate of chicken parmesan, a seafood pasta packed with fresh flavors, or their legendary house-made meatballs, Carmine’s never disappoints. Their garlic bread alone is reason enough to visit (seriously, don’t skip it). And if the weather’s nice, the outdoor patio is the place to be—perfect for people-watching with a glass of wine in hand.
Carmine’s is my go-to for everything from laid-back lunches to celebratory dinners with friends and family. If you’re craving Italian food that’s big on flavor and tradition, this is the spot
Gold Coast Italian: Explore Chicago’s Top Restaurants for Authentic Italian Cuisine
From refined tasting menus to cozy, family-style feasts, the Gold Coast’s Italian dining scene offers something for every palate. These restaurants hold a special place in my heart (and taste buds!), serving up exceptional cuisine and warm hospitality that would make any nonna proud. Mangia!
Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a bowl of soul-warming pasta, the Gold Coast delivers the true essence of Italian dining. From upscale, modern takes to charming neighborhood gems, these beloved eateries ensure you’ll always find the perfect Italian experience.